A plug chop is still a decent (quick, free and easy) indicator of extreme conditions - Black = rich, White = lean.
However, the color variations are more grey even when within fairly good jetting range, and definitely wierd when regional fuels with "nitrogen" "techron" and who knows what else added.
So, being that you are already getting Black or White, you need to get into the gas analyzer (sniffer) testing to go any further.
What kind of step is taking you directly from Black to White? Usually, you can only go to opposite ends of the color range with VERY significant mixture changes.