I sent the following inquiry to Ken Sprayson regarding Norton frames ;
Dear Mr Sprayson,
Thank you for your recent article on frames, but I would like to know your opinion on the use of 531 made Manx frames.
After a season’s use do you recommend the owner to heat up the tubes to stress relieve to prevent cracking/
If so should it be done in or out of a frame jig?
Also, would you recommend the same treatment on the road going frames?
On behalf of other interested parties, thank you for your informative comments.
And got the following reply;
Subject: Kens answer to your email dated 14/8/14
Reynolds 531 tubing is a high tensile material ( 45-50 ton/sq/ins), but having the versatility of mild steel. There is no need for any pre or post heat treatment when used for structural assemblies, though welding sequence should be observed, evening out welding constructions. 531 is suitable for fusion welding providing rapid quenching is avoided. Arc welding. Is not usually recommended due to the short heat affected area and the possible "notch effect" of the weld fillet. When using light gauges (ie 17 or 17 swg) bronze welding or small fillet TIG welding is recommended.
Welded assemblies at Reynolds Tube never needed stress relieving even in the war time aircraft assemblies, though care was taken in design and construction to avoid notch effects and stress raisers.
The experience gained in manufacturing the thousands of aircraft fuselage sections and engine mountings helped in the development and elimination of problems in the all welded motorcycle frames of 1950s and 1960s on.
Regards
Dave ( for Ken )
Dear Mr Sprayson,
Thank you for your recent article on frames, but I would like to know your opinion on the use of 531 made Manx frames.
After a season’s use do you recommend the owner to heat up the tubes to stress relieve to prevent cracking/
If so should it be done in or out of a frame jig?
Also, would you recommend the same treatment on the road going frames?
On behalf of other interested parties, thank you for your informative comments.
And got the following reply;
Subject: Kens answer to your email dated 14/8/14
Reynolds 531 tubing is a high tensile material ( 45-50 ton/sq/ins), but having the versatility of mild steel. There is no need for any pre or post heat treatment when used for structural assemblies, though welding sequence should be observed, evening out welding constructions. 531 is suitable for fusion welding providing rapid quenching is avoided. Arc welding. Is not usually recommended due to the short heat affected area and the possible "notch effect" of the weld fillet. When using light gauges (ie 17 or 17 swg) bronze welding or small fillet TIG welding is recommended.
Welded assemblies at Reynolds Tube never needed stress relieving even in the war time aircraft assemblies, though care was taken in design and construction to avoid notch effects and stress raisers.
The experience gained in manufacturing the thousands of aircraft fuselage sections and engine mountings helped in the development and elimination of problems in the all welded motorcycle frames of 1950s and 1960s on.
Regards
Dave ( for Ken )