An attempt was made in the past to catalog different fenders and stays. I am not sure how good of a job we did, but here is the thread:
fenders-and-stays-t12462.html?hilit=fender
Joe, if you are still monitoring this thread, I am still curious about the front fender off my '74 Mk2 which has a formed trailing edge. I have every reason to believe it came off the showroom floor with that fender, but I have yet to see another with that same trailing edge.
Anybody have a stainless fender with a formed trailing edge?
Is it possible you have the fender turned backward. The leading edge is formed normally...is yours?