Spintron tests

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
313
Country flag
In the car world, and especially Nascar where the pushrod engine is the standard, the valve train is frequently tested using Spintron equipment.Such tests show up all kinds of abnormalities such as bending pushrods, valve spring surge, lofting, bounce, and much more. I'm wondering if anyone has had the opportunity to have such tests run to evaluate the Commando valve gear.
If anyone has I'm sure quite a few members would appreciate seeing the details of some of the test results.
 
Never heard of this being done on a clunker Commando so please be the first to show us the elastic nature on a full tilt boggey spintron test.
 
hobot, I know you are familiar with the Spintron and what it is capable of, but many may not realise exactly what it is .
Try the following to get a good rundown on the equipment and it's use
www://trendperformance.com/files/Brochu ... torial.pdf
You'll notice that a hog has been tested, but mainly the Nascar V8's. Very, very expensive equipment to use for evaluating a single or twin cylinder pushrod motorcycle engine, I don't know personally of anyone who has done it, hence my original question.
I have used Spintron equipment in the past, but only when working on a V8. I also use a computer program which I have found by comparison is so good and compares extremely well with Spintron results. This is handy for me, I can carry it around on my laptop.
The computer program allows the user to evaluate all aspects of the valve train, but it does one thing not possible with the Spintron - it can simulate the exhaust valve opening against the high cylinder pressure in a firing engine. This latter shows up the exhaust valve opening in a different light, and can be much of the reason for an opening lag of some considerable number of crankshaft degrees, especially when compared to a motored simulation, where the situation would be identical to that using the Spintron.
Anyone timing up an engine might congratulate themselves in having split hairs to get events exactly to the designers spec, but in a pushrod engine valve events will be much different dynamically, and the more so as the revs rise and the loadings increase. Whether the original designer knew this and made allowances in his design is doubtful, but for certain there are some very useful gains to be had when a designer learns how to take these discrepancies into account, and makes a plan to have them working for him, rather than against. When I find out how to post a picture, I'll try to add a couple to illustrate.
 
Ever seen the Navy Dive Tables? They were developed by the Navy by sending divers to a specified depth for a period of time and then bringing them to the surface to see if they got bent or not. I am guessing that by now this is more the standard for Commando valve train evaluation.

Russ
 
Yep I've been dependent on dive time and depth N2 absorption and discharge rates charts on both plain ole air and also mixed gases of rebreathers w/o bubbles to know that no one can take into account the basic health faults and unknown conditions of the diver, so the final fine tuning limits only happens in each case as failure crisis occurs. Spintron is not done in real life heat and combustion and drive load conditions so we are left to the time proven way of run to failure then correct that then repeat and repeat as much as can afford.

I do sort of relate motorcyclers to cave divers, never know if you or your buddies will return on their own power or even at all.

Here's some video to envision what our clunkers are doing faster than intended.
http://www.youtube.com/results?search_q ... my6MarQbNQ
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top