Rohan said:
We are only talking a few thou on the cylinder centreline here ??
The question really is did Nortons design it like that, or is it that it grew like topsy, and thats the measurement they ended up with ??
=============================================
Dunno Nortons actual thinking on this topic,, or if it was what they thought would make things line up better? have no idea.
What I DO know is that, (very simplified explanation here,,there is a lot of engineering and indepth articles out there on this if you care to research it) with a motor the cylinder being in perfect alignment straight up and down, the thinking is its hard at TDC and BDC on the parts, cranks pushed out the bottom, bearings stressed, loads on the skirts of the pistons, stress's on the rods, etc etc,,,
So some designers felt that by offsetting the cylinder slightly from centerline might make things a bit easier,, tipping over the cliff so to speak,,
Eddy and I did a lot of research on this, im sure others consulted as well, but about 5-6 years back when we did that, but found the best material related to Toyota and their engine designs, and yes, apparently they do it on most if not all their engines,.,
So Eddy felt that Norton got it wrong, in mockups and testing he said the Norton Cylinder IS offset a bit, but claimed it was the wrong direction, Next time i saw the cases for the racer, he had trued up all the surfaces, and moved the studs to where he thought they should be,, Backside direction IIRC correctly,,
This was all some time ago, and Sir Eddy is no longer with us, but theres plenty of material on this topic out there.
Now in contrast, most if not all Norton cases are dimensionally off a bit anyway,, some more than others, Eddy would blue print cases for people, correct the factory maufacturing deviations. He did some BSA cases for me as well on a twin, those were way off, I took a series of pix of him doing this and im afraid i have been busy as of late but planned ot post a picture series of some of these blue printing techniques these were done about 15 months ago in Eddys shop and show interesting details about how far off things can be,
Theres a local guy who some years back kept seizing his Goldstar engine while racing, Eddy looked at it and said it was obvious what was wrong, you could see the marks on the cylinder and piston, but the guy balked at the price, (Jeez, its a GS for christs sake,, how much wouldit cost to replace if he grenaded it?)
so the guy, I wont name him, reassy his motor, went racing, and seized it up again. It was redundant to say "I told you so"