auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 24, 2005
Messages
198
I would like to get some opinions from the group as to the REAL benefit of fitting an auto. cam chain tensioner,anyone got one on their bike?, any noticeable change?.Thanks in advance. Ride safely. James.
 

Jerry Doe

Admin
Joined
May 21, 2003
Messages
2,053
Country flag
Auto cam chain tensioner for Norton Commando

Great question as I am thinking about one.

I did not fit the auto tensioner as I read an article about them failing.

So what do you all think?
 
Joined
Apr 7, 2004
Messages
1,691
Never heard of one braking well there was one guy with a locked throttle who did 10,000 rpms .LOL Taking Dyno Dave's advice wouldn't even think of running a Norton without one. It seems that the uneven loads on the cam as it travels through it's rotation couldn't help but make the timing a bit jumpy.
 
Joined
Apr 7, 2004
Messages
1,691
RMA Engineering in San Jose, CA Makes them some vender's now carry them in stock for a mark up. Kelly Cork in Australia makes one out of a Nissan car part that works well and is cheaper.
The RMA pushes from underneath and outside the chain and requires slight case mods. Kelly corks runs inside the chain and pushes down no case mods needed. RMA's provides constant spring tension were as Kelly's has an internal ratchet device that indexes about every .030 of chain slackening. Sorry no shopping baskets for these products unless you pay a mark up from a big house. maybe you could get them up some web sites and make it easier for all of us.
 
Joined
Oct 19, 2005
Messages
1,603
Country flag
I have an RMA in one bike and a Cork Engineering model in another. I have not had trouble with either although the 'Cork' model needed modification to the mounting arrangement to get it to fit an early Commando with the cam-shaft breather. The RMA model states in the fitting literature that you may have to file a slight flat on one of the inner bosses where the timing cover screws fit into - a 3-minute job done in-situ for even the most mechanically insensitive amongst us.

Oscilating timing caused by loose chains allied to the mechanical points system on the first Combat motors were supposedly a large factor in the legendary unreliability of these models. I would not run a Norton without one. To adjust the cam-chain correctly is time consuming and requires the use of a new oil pump end seal and probably a new timimg cover gasket as well as some kind of special tool arrangement to support the intermediate gear shaft.

On balance I would fit another RMA unit because the Cork ones are not easy to get hold of. Norvil sells the RMA unit but the company is based in the USA so may be available from other sources.
 
Joined
Apr 15, 2004
Messages
1,616
Country flag
RMA Engineering usually has an ad in the Norton News although I don't see it in the latest issue. From an older issue, here is contact info:

(408) 578-4032
Rmaten4@att.net

They're in San Jose. It's a husband and wife business, good people.

If you don't get one I would at least replace the timing chain.

Debby
 
Joined
Aug 24, 2005
Messages
198
Many, many thanks to all who replied,it appears to be a " no brainer",my cheque is on the way to RMA. Ride safely. James
 
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
1,041
Country flag
I asked Pete Lovell (a Norton engineer in the UK) about these last year, and although he didn't say to me don't get one, he expressed an opinion that they possibly ran the cam chain a bit tight, and that he was not totally convinced in their worth. Having said that I have never heard of any catastrophes with one.

The near maintainence free aspect is appealing though.
 
Joined
Apr 12, 2012
Messages
30
I have installed one in my '71 Commando. The instructions detail a hydraulic lock method of holding things in place while the left hand thread oil pump nut is being undone. I stuffed a long piece of nylon rope into the combustion chamber of one piston on the compression stroke, with both valves closed, which worked fine.

The tensioner seems to be of very good quality.
 
Joined
Jan 12, 2011
Messages
1,723
Country flag
Ten years ago I installed the spring loaded cam chain tensioner from RMA, and I regret very much doing so.

ADVANTAGE: you don't have to take off your timing cover and re position the stock sliding tensioner, this is rightfully perceived as an inconvenience every 5000 miles as specified in the workshop manaul


DISADVANTAGE: The spring loaded tensioner, in my opinion, puts too much pressure on the cam chain, in fact it over tightens it SO MUCH that, in my case, it created an oblong hole out of my intermediate gear spindle locating hole which necessitated an expensive welding repair and reconstruction.

Jim Mosher, of Performance Indian, and builder of the Bonneville Norton unfaired record holder, rebuilt my motor three years ago and called me when he had it torn apart to report the damage the RMA cam tensioner had done.
He insisted that he would not continue my rebuild unless i agreed to allow him to put the stock sliding tensioner back in in place after he finished rebuilding the damage done.

Here is the "other" problem: You cannot know IF any damage is being done from the very tight cam chain unless you take the timing cover off AND remove the chain in order to inspect the intermediate gear locating spindle hole to check for elongation. You CAN ride your Norton in blissful uncertainty for quite a while figuring everything in there is just hunky dory.

Just my own experience, but no way would I ever use anything but the stock slider, I learned my lesson.
 
Joined
Jun 1, 2003
Messages
2,139
Country flag
there is absolutely no way I would use one. the customer service is non existent and it is extremely hard on the cam bushings, timing chain, sprockets and idler gear pin. here is the remains of one he refused to warranty.

auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)
 

batrider

VIP MEMBER
Joined
Aug 9, 2008
Messages
2,290
Country flag
Contradicting evidence and bad horror stories on this one. Never on my bike.

Russ
 
Joined
Jul 25, 2010
Messages
5,487
Country flag
Oh Dear : :( NOW , ' we ' all know not to play Tarzan on the spanners in the timing case , unless the cam spindle support cover is on ( see below )

Heres a gnatty ford ' kent ' pushrod 59 - 75 cam chain tensioner , light hairpin type spring , single row chain . unlikely itll go in there though . :?: :?

auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


" The timing chain tensioner pad is a wear item and should be replaced at every engine rebuild. The tensioner spring can also weaken with age, making the tensioner ineffective and upsetting cam and ignition timing. " http://images.google.com.au/imgres?imgu ... oQrQMwADgU

The chainplate links should wear trenches in the buffer pad , so as the rollers roll on the pad surface . then its ' run in ' . 8) if its down to the metal , its ' run out ' . :cry: :oops:

auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


NOW , EVERYONEs got one of THESE or Those hanging on the workshop wall . Havnt They . :( :p

auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


its not painfull at all . the wherewithall timing-cover-cutaway-t13071.html?hilit=timing%20cover%20cuttaway from your Friends at ACCESS NORTON . :D
 
Joined
Oct 19, 2005
Messages
18,978
Country flag
RMA cam tensioner = Bad JuJu. Here's years of reviews to study up & make your call. Other RMA/ Rick&Mary Associates, products are worthwhile.

http://www.google.ca/webhp?hl=en&tab=ww ... =p&pdl=300

Btw 10 grand will only get needle to bounce a bit off backside of needle stop, takes sickening more to bounce it so fast its invisible. Crank shaft end wobble can jerk the snort out of cam chain tension at some rpm jump rope threshold. Test this yourself please and get back to us.
 

dero

VIP MEMBER
Joined
Jan 22, 2010
Messages
215
Country flag
I got mine from Norvil , done a lot of miles , have not looked inside since but running fine .
 

johnm

VIP MEMBER
Joined
Feb 26, 2008
Messages
1,314
Country flag
I had a Kelly Cork one in my 500 Dominator race bike for about 10 years.

The bike went well and maybe this can in part be attributed to cam control aided by the tensioner.

However recently I took the timing cover off and found the whole thing moving about and it had partly ground itself into the cam sprocket.

So on the good side

- it worked for 10 years on a race bike regularly ridden at 7200 rpm.

- I cannot see any problems with over tightening of the chain. No worn spindle mounting holes etc.

On the not good side

-it is a bit of a fiddle to fit and needed grinding of the backing plate and from memory machining part of the sprocket on a lath ??? to get enough clearance. (It was 10 years ago)

-The mounting plate eventualy fretted loose. There is not much space in there and its all held together with one nut on a thin (1/4" but dont quote me?) stud. (See the photo in one of the referenced links above)

My view is the concept is good but it kind of feels like an after market comprimise squashed into too small a space for the whole thing to be really robust.

For a race bike with regular inspection worth it - probably yes.

For a street bike - probably no. I dont intend to fit one in my street Mk 11 Commando.
 
Joined
Oct 19, 2005
Messages
18,978
Country flag
The racers were the first to test the various alternatives to realize the best cam tensioner so far, is a well worn chain link edge grooved surface the link rollers can surf on an oil layer.

auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)
 

slimslowslider

VIP MEMBER
Joined
Jun 29, 2010
Messages
284
Country flag
Here's a bunch of pics of the kelly cork one I fitted.
So far say 6000km. No issues yet. Any noticable difference? Maybe she runs more regular stationary, but might be wishfull hearing.

auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)


auto. cam chain tensioner (2007)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top