There is no reason for this, but it is what it is. I had purchased a 1/8 woodruff key and I took the cam sprocket/gear with me when I did. It was a very snug fit. Took it home and it was loose in the cam. Dug out the 000572 key and it was a snug fit in the cam and a no go in the gear.
II went back and measured all the keyways with my calibrated equipment.
cam keyway measured width -
88 well used 0.130"
daytona well used 0.130"
factory domi special * 0.125"
commando grass track outfit race cam 0.126"
dunstall domi cam * 0.129"
new 2s 0.1245"
new commando std cam 0.125"
(* all 3 keyways measured)
sprocket keyway 0.1275"
sprocket keyway (dynamo) 0.127"
My findings are that -
well used cams tend to have worn keyways
the dunstall cam had oversize keyways from new
factory cams had 0.125" keyways
sprocket keyways are slightly oversize and do not wear like the cams owing to a greater contact area or harder material.
My conclusions -
If the sprocket will not fit on the key check for burrs or other damage/contamination on the key or keyway. if no damage is found carefully dress the key to just fit in the keyway. Do any filing well away from the engine. (A thou or 2 is not going to upset the timing.)
I recall that the last key I used I made from a bolt shank (grade 8.8 is perfect, not stainless steel) to fit.