Hey Nigel,
I bought an 09 XR1200 last weekend. This is the only bike I've ever owned with an electric start. It's fast, a bit heavy, loud and handles (for a Harley). Wanted something I could go reliably long distance, also something a bit "sporty". This is the only Harley that fit the bill in my price range, plus it looks cool.
I also own this 1972 xlch. This was the first Harley I bought. I was impressed with the build quality, simplicity and reliability. It's a classic American machine. Not fast, but has a sweet spot in third gear that feels great.
I am not a "Harley" guy, I am a motorcycle guy. I like that HD is an American motorcycle. Big old cruisers don't appeal much to me but that's ok, I can't afford one anyway, nor have we got the roads around here. You don't need to own a Harley to see the failures in their line up, not a lot of variety.
Here is an FTR I ran into the other day.. Also a bike I would consider buying, too expensive right now, in a few years maybe... Much smaller than I expected, fun looking.
Still think if I could get 20 more HP out of my commando and a good windscreen it would be the best bike in the world haha.