I'm in the anything but Amal camp.
I purchased my first Commando in '99. Without really giving the Amals a chance, had a mikuni fitted. This was because of some vague recollection i had of an article in, I think, Cycle magazine titled "The Mikuni Connection". It raved about the improved behavior with the mikuni. It gave me great service. Many thousands of miles, including an Iron Butt 1000 miles in a day run.
Three years ago, I had amals fitted before a 7 state 3000 plus mile ride to the INOA ralley in Torrey Utah. They were amazing... for about 800 miles. I spent the last 2500 miles on about one and a half cylinders.
I've had them looked at, both on and off the bike by really good Norton people for the last 3 years. Finally thought I had the settled before heading for Lumby last month. Again, they were a revelation... for another 2 and a half days and 750 miles or so. after that I spent another 1000 miles of ill running, backfiring, hard starting, plug fouling misery.
I 'm not so skilled that I can do a carb teardown on the road. Even if I could, those kind of adventures are not as much fun as the once were. If I were planning on more long distance rides, I might consider the twin 32 keihins. However, after this last frustration, I'll either stick to a more modern ride or trailer the rascal. I still have the mikuni, and am planning on reinstalling it.
So much seems to be luck. Many riders I'm spoken to have had the Amals for many thousands of miles with no problems. Many others, and maybe many more others, just can't catch a break with the little boogers.
But ya know what? It's still grand to be riding a Norton!