Many years ago when I rebuilt my crankcase, I had no clue about crankcase breather modifications, and I did my best to get all my surfaces mated tightly, gasket joints tightened down properly, and parts assembled without doing damage to newly installed seals. I still had some leaks that I couldn't completely stop or wasn't aware of the modification to fix them. (tachometer drive) So, I suffered with a bike that always ended up with a coating of oil on it from slow, persistant leaks because I didn't want to clean my bike everytime I rode it.
I was aware that there were guys who could rebuild a norton without any leakage. My buddy Paul, paid "Dr. Bob" in new jersey to rebuild his bike and it didn't leak way back in the 80's, so I knew it was possible. I'm not a professional mechanic, so I didn't have the "Dr bob" touch, and I had some leaks on my bike, but at least I rebuilt my bike myself.
I accepted that most nortons have some leakage and I was unaffected by all the classic comments like: "oh look, your bike is marking it's spot". My bike leaked! I accepted that....
......but I'm not stupid, and even though I didn't innovate the solution to certain problems of the commando design, I am smart enough to recognize good solutions. Many of which, I have added to my bike. Once I did the breather mod to my bike all the crankcase leaks stopped, and because my bike wasn't covered in oil, I was able to see that I had a gearbox leak too, so I rebuilt that recently also. I used a little silicone on the primary cover rope and bingo, dry bike... mind-effing-blowing....
For ME,.... the turning point was the breather modification which cured my minor crankcase leakage. Even though I didn't go for the comstock breather solution because I don't have the money nor the patience to tear down my bike again, I did "go to school" on his use of the reed valve to reduce crankcase pressure on all my joints, gaskets and seals... Hence, I am pretty happy to have a dry back wheel ...
I feel that with the help of the forum search function and the many people who shared their information here I am going to have a norton, that not only doesn't have an oily back wheel most of the time, but will soon be tracking very precisely at high speeds with the help of the new head steady I am psyched to add to my non-leaking bike....
I ran it up to 90mph today and it barely weaved at all, but my feet were buzzing a little because I had the isolatics too tight after reassembling the iso's after the gearbox rebuild and reinstall... I am pretty psyched.... as you can probably tell...