MK3 clack in primary

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Oct 28, 2014
Messages
1,996
Country flag
I am assuming the clack sound in the primary when I turn the throttle up is the chain and the tensioner. All the electric start gearing is gone. Is it possible to eliminate the clack? It's usually one good whack or two and then settles down. I am running ATF in the primary but I seem to recall the same clack no matter what oil I run....and it happens only with MK3. I believe the oil is draining out of the tensioner when it sits idle then needs to be resupplied as it runs to get full tension. Second question...is this a good tensioner or does it have its faults?
 
seattle##gs said:
Is it possible to eliminate the clack? It's usually one good whack or two and then settles down.


It doesn't seem to cause any problems and the noise stops once the tensioner has re-primed so I think it's something most Mk3 owners accept and learn to live with.


seattle##gs said:
I am running ATF in the primary but I seem to recall the same clack no matter what oil I run....and it happens only with MK3.

20W/50 motorcycle oil certainly reduced the amount of knocking and my Mk3's tensioner works better (when primed) with 20W/50 in the primary.



seattle##gs said:
Second question...is this a good tensioner or does it have its faults?

It seems to be a reasonably reliable device, at least I don't recall hearing of one either breaking or stop working. The only time it didn't seem to work properly for me was with ATF in the primary.
 
The thinner oil (ATF) will weep out the lower plunger and the tensioner loses it's prime. Then, enough oil has to drip off the chain to re-prime the plungers to take up the slack. Stick with what the book recommends (engine oil, which was mostly straight 50 at the time) and the problem is reduced if not eliminated. I'm not hearing a clack beyond the first startup after a layup.
 
When I bought my Mark III I immediately drained the primary and filled it with ATF, amongst other fluid changes. From then on, when I started the engine cold, the sound of chain slap alarmed me for the first minute or so of running, especially at idle. Then I drained the ATF and filled the primary with the same oil I run in the engine, Mobil 1 v-twin 20-50. It has never made a sound since. A miracle, it is!
 
Danno said:
Stick with what the book recommends (engine oil, which was mostly straight 50 at the time)

Although the original Mk3 recommendation was for either monograde SAE 40-SAE 50 or 20W/50 multigrade for the engine, only 20W/50 was recommended for the primary case.
 
My 850 is a Mk.1 1973 so doesn't have a hydraulic tensioner but I've used ATF in the primary case for years mainly to prevent clutch drag. I would have thought 20/50 or straight 40 or 50 would produce bad clutch drag?
 
Do not engine oils have friction reducing inhibitors in them these days?? Just what you need when the clutch is dependant upon the coefficient of friction acting between the friction interfaces so it handles the torque being put intop it without slip occuring....... What is wrong wioth a straight SAE20 oil In my young days Castrolite was the oil of choice for primary lubrication but Castrol tell me it is no longer available. Either Silkolene or Morris oils flog straight SAE 20 in quart pots. AND DONT FORGET you do NOT fill to the oil level plug...200cc only as per section K8 in the manual and ignore the old section K8 instruction to fill to the oil level plug which some 'brain' at NVT went and put in as the new section K9 when introducing the new section K8............
 
daveparry said:
I would have thought 20/50 or straight 40 or 50 would produce bad clutch drag?

20W/50 doesn't, I have no idea if SAE 40 or 50 does (not recommended oil so haven't tried it).


J. M. Leadbeater said:
Do not engine oils have friction reducing inhibitors in them these days??

No, not all of them (I think you mean friction modifiers). Perhaps you know a gentleman who can explain JASO classifications to you?

If not?:
http://www.oilspecifications.org/articl ... ASO_MB.php
http://www.opieoils.co.uk/c-1296-jaso-m ... e-oil.aspx
http://www.whitedogbikes.com/whitedogbl ... -ma2-mean/



J. M. Leadbeater said:
Either Silkolene or Morris oils flog straight SAE 20 in quart pots.

I think you mean litres? My Mk3 gets the same Morris V Twin 20W/50 (and yes, I am aware my Commando isn't actually a V-twin) in the primary as I use for the engine so no there's need to waste money buying two different oils when the same one does both jobs.

http://www.morrislubricantsonline.co.uk ... e-oil.html


J. M. Leadbeater said:
AND DONT FORGET you do NOT fill to the oil level plug...200cc only as per section K8 in the manual and ignore the old section K8 instruction to fill to the oil level plug which some 'brain' at NVT went and put in as the new section K9 when introducing the new section K8...........

Running the Mk3 primary oil level lower than the level plug only serves to starve the tensioner and delay the priming process and I don't find filling to the level plug causes clutch slip regardless of some other 'brain' continually insisting that it does.
 
Deets55 said:
Check to see if there is a gasket between parts #29 and #27. It does not show up on some (maybe all) parts diagrams. It would be part # 06-6570. Also make sure part # 29 is flat.

http://www.oldbritts.com/1975_g10.html


Pete

Double ditto on Pete's opinion. No gasket or a warped plate will only exaggerate the problem. I'm not sure how the plate gets warped but I found mine not flat. Also pay close attention to the proper torque values for reassembly.

Here is a article I wrote a few years ago on the MKIII primary chain tensioner.
Please keep in mind this only applies to MKII's

Tuesday, April 29, 2008

The Continuing Adventures of The Buckeye Rider

The Hydraulic Primary Chain Tensioner
As Fitted to the MKIII Commando

‘Pa’ my trusty Norton is a MKIII model from 1975, this makes him different from all earlier Commando models because the engine and transmission are fixed in place and the slack in the primary chain is not adjusted by moving the units away from each other. This is taken care of by a two piston vertically opposed self-filling hydraulic tensioner. The tensioner expands automatically as the chain wears keeping the chain tight and the power transmitted from the engine to the gearbox constant. Or that’s the way it’s supposed to work!

When spring arrives in South West Ohio that means its time to go to the shed and perform the annual inspection and major service. While I’m inside the primary chain case taking care of business I notice that the chain is rather slack and decide to have a go at the tensioner and see what it’s about. The only mention in the service book is that the tensioner requires no maintenance. The book should be amended to read “Service Every Thirty-Three Years”.

The tensioner pistons were not filled with oil as they were supposed to be so the only force they had to tension the chain was from the small internal springs. The tensioner was removed from its mounting studs as a unit and the top and bottom portions were marked so as to install them later into there original bores.
Inside the piston is the spring and a white plastic mushroom headed spacer. The spacer is inserted into the piston small end first so the big end is toward the spring. This spacer is used as a damper to slow the passage of oil into and out of the cavity created by the shape of the spacer inside the piston. There is a very small bleeder hole through the piston that leaks oil into the cylinder bore and lubricates the outside of the piston and the bore.
Connecting the two vertically opposed cylinders is a small orifice so the two units can share the oil from a common reservoir.
The shape of the top half of the tensioner and a dual-purpose cover plate forms the reservoir. At the lower end of the reservoir is a simple ball and spring one way check valve that lets oil pass into the tensioner.
When all is working as planned the tensioner is self- adjusting, self- bleeding and maintenance free. Except when the pistons accumulate sludge and the tiny orifices get clogged up and small pieces of I don’t know what fall into the oil reservoir after 35 k miles.

The tensioner was carefully disassembled, cleaned, inspected then studied to understand how it all works. The inside of both parts of the case were also cleaned and the primary chain inspected and replaced.
To assemble I turned the empty pistons upside down and filled them with oil then inserted the white plastic spacer (small end first) then the spring. Then the top bore was filled and the piston inserted then the dripping mess was inverted and the bottom bore filled and the piston installed. The tensioner is now filled and there should be no air inside but the unit cannot be depressed enough to install it on the mounting studs and make it fit between the two rows of chain. While holding the tensioner unit with the fingers of one hand and applying slight pressure to compress the pistons take a small pick and depress the one way check valve just enough to let the tensioner slip in between the chain snuggly. Install a new gasket ( p/n 06-6570 not illustrated in the parts book) and the dual purpose cover plate and tighten as directed. Fill the reservoir with oil.
The tensioner should now be very tight on the chain, allowing the two pistons to move up and down as a unit but be unable to be compressed.
The cover has two purposes. One is to form the oil reservoir for the tensioner the other is to catches the oil that is flung by the chain and directing it into the reservoir, keeping it full.
Fill the primary case with 7oz. (200cc) of the oil of your choice; we won’t get into an oil thread here. I have used both ATF and several weights of motor oil with the differing results. But the “correct” oil would be whatever you have in the engine. (IMHO)

The corrected primary chain tensioner was noticed instantly with a smoother and quieter idle and smoother operation at cruising speed and a noticeable increase in performance when torque was demanded.

If, after many years of service, the primary chain is in need of replacement this is the perfect opportunity to replace the crankshaft main seal. After all the work involved in removing the primary chain the main seal is only another fifteen minutes deeper behind the alternator.
Is there anything as fulfilling as riding a British motorcycle at speed when you have done all the work yourself, and everything is working as it should in harmony with all the other parts?
Ride On
Dave

© Dave Mathers
The Buckeye Rider
Cincinnati, Ohio
4/29/2008
 
If it continues beyond warm up then one of the tensioners is jammed - the spring tries to escape. Inner lower chaincase will have witness marks also.
 
J. M. Leadbeater said:
Do not engine oils have friction reducing inhibitors in them these days?? Just what you need when the clutch is dependant upon the coefficient of friction acting between the friction interfaces so it handles the torque being put intop it without slip occuring....... What is wrong wioth a straight SAE20 oil In my young days Castrolite was the oil of choice for primary lubrication but Castrol tell me it is no longer available. Either Silkolene or Morris oils flog straight SAE 20 in quart pots. AND DONT FORGET you do NOT fill to the oil level plug...200cc only as per section K8 in the manual and ignore the old section K8 instruction to fill to the oil level plug which some 'brain' at NVT went and put in as the new section K9 when introducing the new section K8............

Motorcycle-specific oils do not have friction modifiers such as molybdenum disulfide. Any oil that does should specify so on the label. If you do not fill a Mk III primary to the level plug, there won't be enough splash to fill the tensioner (which also lowers the level below the plug) and still have enough to wet the chain. As much as we'd like the tensioner to be a sealed unit, it isn't and it loses it's prime when the engine sits for a time. If you change the primary oil (always a good idea after a layoff since it runs a little colder than the engine oil but warmer than the gearbox) you have to fill to the level plug. You can go by capacity if you are doing as described above and priming the tensioner before you button up the case.
 
upon investgating, the chain is stretched and is whacking the cases top and bottom. I filled with #30 non detergent and will see what happens.
 
By experience, if the chain is whacking the case top and bottom, then the hydraulic tensioner is going to be clogged with aluminum sludge and will not operate correctly until it is cleaned out.
The check valve in the bottom of the reservoir is very small and will get blocked easily.
Ride On
Dave
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top