Couldn't that be part of the problem ?
I hear lots of praise for a PW3 cam , but for city riding ? .. 5 deg retarded , plus chain stretch and valvetrain flex will retard it even more , this makes for a pretty late closing inlet valve . I can't help but think that this must have a negative effect on a stable idle . Maybe a camshaft expert can give his opinion on this ?
This is how its always been. Bike came in early '98 with a Fred Barlow version of 2S cam, massive intake lift etc but kind of std timing, knackered carbs. Rubbish in town of course. New carbs added, just the same when hot. I rebuilt with std. cam when the engine blew end '02. No real change in town use.
PW3 cam added early '10. Just the same in town. You can hear the idle in attached video, its perfectly stable until something changes. I've built small block GM and Ford engines with high lift cams (low vacuum - erratic idle) and they were 'rumpy' but the PW3 is pretty good in this respect. The reason I have it on std timing marks is that it was not as tractable set to designed timing which just happened to be 5deg advanced over std marks. I am doubtless missing some top end and no, I would not fit another. It may be very good at 7000+ rpm but the std cam is far nicer and not noticeably slower in my engine. One reason I bought it was the Norton experts claim that it improved the mid range substantially. I do not think so, certainly not on specified timing. Both of those experts are well respected so I will not say any more. The Barlow '2S' was far more exciting as a piece of performance equipment but lousy for tractability.
How rich do you believe it has t o be when you see black smoke coming out of the exhaust ? Even with the chokes on you should not see that. If you have cut the slides, you have probably lost control of the situation. Perhaps you should buy a new standard set ? I suggest you should strip the carburettors, clean and check that all the jets are clear without pushing anything through them that could scratch. Rebuild the carbs, checking the float levels, and that the float valve is not obstructed. Then you will have a decent starting point. I would be careful of in-line filters , check that you have sufficient fuel flow through them.
Good point AC but I have had chokes on this bike and it has produced a little black (not blue or white) smoke with full choke and throttle opened. Not clouds of the stuff but just enough to know.
Carbs are clean, 100psi of air and thinners through all openings. Did consider the possible reduced flow but at idle? 220 Main jets are only 0.050" dia.
The fact remains that she idles fine until the temperature is elevated or some kind of mysterious blockage occurs and leaves no trace after!
Listen to the vid, the idle is lovely, a bit sharp but that's the cam. If it stayed like that I'd be very happy but it goes from perfect to shit in a matter of seconds.
I think it has to be a blockage and like you I'm thinking what idiot puts up with this for nearly 15 years. I have lots of faults and one is going down the same route time after time (no lateral thinking

). As an example I spent 3 years trying to get the clutch to release cleanly (IN TRAFFIC - WHERE ELSE!!), plate cleaning, adjusting, changing lever pivots etc. I then found I had a Dommie actuating arm installed and when a Commando item didn't completely solve it I pulled the diaphragm and found it distorted. It wasn't lifting evenly. Most of my riding is as expected on the open road so these 'problems' are tolerated because the situations under which they occur are avoided.
Here she is running before I pulled the bowls. Ran for 10 mins with no problem this time:roll:
http://youtu.be/QPu5nqrMpGU